Friday, 25 July 2014

Hard or Soft? Training that is...

  



 


Listening to the old guard it might be suggested that “Hard” is the best way, in fact to many it’s the only way!
“It’s not like the old days, training was hard tough and only a few survived…..

Hand mitts, pah hand mitts are for wimps, we used to use broken glass… (Only in films though right)?

“Well we trained on a solid wooden floor”. “A wooden floor, ooooh I used to lie awake at night dreaming of a wooden floor, we trained in a snake pit with on a floor of nails,” etcetera etcetera (al a Monty Python)
.
Well is tough training really better, and what is tough training anyway? Is it discipline in a class which is enforced with a shinai (been there). Is it pushing your physical limits to the point of collapse and then going again? (Been there too). Is it the repetition of a technique so many times your arms feel like they are no longer a part of your body? (Done that).  Is it the endless tedium of kneeling in meditation for 60 minutes before doing a class (clearing your mind and screwing your legs up in the process).

What about the stretching class where you think your bones won’t stay in their sockets any longer and your tendons might never go back to where they belonged? Or a session where you just get punched in the face a lot by someone big and strong or even small and fast (you know the ones I’m talking about).

But hang on a minute, why so hard? As I see it hard training is designed to weed out those who can’t hack it, the weedy of spirit, the lacking in fortitude, the men from the boys! And that’s a good thing right, or is it?

Well isn’t martial arts specifically designed to be able to help those people, the weedy, the calmer more considerate people, monks for example, the people who aren’t big, tough, strong and naturally aggressive.

 Is it right that the people who need martial arts the most to help them protect themselves; are the very people the “hard ways” were designed to weed out?

 This “hard way” of teaching, means that martial art school was left with the students who didn’t need help in tearing off some ones face in the first place. Why did we do this, how did this come about?

 Could it have been the old “school against school” system where a master was judged by how tough their students were, or how they competed against the rest, or how the masters were viewed by their peer group (other martial artists) or just the old ego thing, “my students are harder than yours?” Certainly an “old school” master took little notice of the old lady down the road who had just been mugged, but who wasn’t tough enough to do the class.

So the soft way, the fun classes, the gentle introduction, the skill based lesson with a polite attentive instructor an instructor who is respectful to his students as he was to his sensei, has to have a place, surely teaching a less able student the importance of a knee strike to the groin is much better than seeing if they can do a thousand push ups before you will let them enter the dojo and teach them.

I understand facing violent situations is physically and emotionally demanding, but only teaching those who are quite cool with violence anyway can’t be the right thing to do.  

So Hard or Soft, well I get there is a place for both and those Martial Artists whose objective is to win in a cage or compete against others to prove themselves, will always want hard training, mostly the domain of young men,  but come on, hard core guys, give the rest of us a break, I’ve done my fair share of press ups, had my ribs cracked and on more occasions than I want to recall, received bloody noses bangs and bruises, mostly before many of you were born.

 In those days I enjoyed the rough and tough stuff, these days, I teach those who need the skills I have, I don’t hit my students with a stick (very often), or bend their joints, or bust their ribs, but they enjoy their training, they work to the best of their ability and with a small nudge in the right direction every now and again they improve.

I teach them situational awareness and the importance of understanding violence and it’s the predicable nature. Avoidance, de-escalation and pre-emptive striking, I teach young women about dating safety and the warning signs which may lead to domestic violence. All soft skills and a darn sight more useful than old school way of just being hard. There is so much more to martial arts than “old school hard training” learning how to take a punch by being punched in the face a few hundred times doesn’t cut it in the modern world and as for  gaining those all-important callouses on your knuckles come on…

Hard or soft?  Everyone trains because they ENJOY some aspects of what they do, if students don’t enjoy your lessons they will go and do something else (and you can teach them nothing).

Just a thought, but to keep your students and to do what Martial Arts were designed to do, help protect the less able to defend themselves. You may just need to lighten up.

Respect.




How to get in touch with Mike


Web                                        www.teamblackbelt.com                            Take me there.

Facebook                               Mike Turbitt                                                Take me there.
                                   
Twitter                                    Teamblackbelt                                             Take me there

YouTube Channel                   TeamBlackBelt                                            Take me there.

E Mail                                     mike@teamblackbelt.com





More of Mike’s work,




A Children’s on line video anti bullying 
programme – Stop Bullies Now!





           


How to Build a Black Belt Business

Available as e book or paper back from
Lulu.com or Amazon.co.uk/Amazon.com














Saturday, 5 July 2014

10 Year Old Black Belts...... Really?



So yesterday I saw a face book post regarding a 19 year old who had been awarded his 4th Degree Black Belt, well he had been training for 10 years and was entitled (according to his sensei) to be called a "Master". The post was followed by a number of derogatory comments from various martial artists in the box underneath, including the words Mc Dojo.

It set me thinking, how does this type of thing happen? I know from my 30 years in Karate that 10 Year Old Black Belts are a fairly common sight, from my logo you should guess I teach a large number of children each week.

My thoughts are that when Karate came to the UK  it was the domain of adults, the syllabus was for adults and the time scales applied to that syllabus was for adults.  Four, Five and Six years for a serious student to get to Black Belt, and we teach what we were taught right?

But now the number of children training in the UK  far out number the adults, and children are just little adults, arn't they? So syllabus which have there base in the 1960s with the hard core stuff removed (for kids) still mean five years of training and the students are grading for a Black Belt. 

So is the school awarding a Black Belt to a 10 or 12 year old student who has trained two or three times a week for 5, 6 or even 7 years, wrong to award that student a Black Belt? After all the same amount of training would gain the award for almost all adult students.

The Student in this case  can wave there arms and legs about in just the same way as many of there adult counter parts, (some times better) and do what is required by a syllabus, some may be able to fight against there peer group, but really we all know they are not able to protect themselves to any real degree in the real world. ( an abductor would just pick them up and carry them away , or slap them and make them cry).

It is my belief that the holder of a Black Belt should have a reasonable chance of defending themselves in the real world, against real adults and that they would surely need a certain amount of physical development and strength, a certain amount of maturity and the ability to use aggression and take and inflict pain. Not traits usually associated with young children.

 In school terms I think a Black Belt award  its at least comparable to a GCSE, possibly an A level, (and some may think degree level).

We start a childs' education at nursery school at the age of three or four years old, however  it is a truly exceptional child who gains an GCSE before the age of fourteen. The whole school teaching structure, system and syllabus is aimed to the awarding of GCSEs when a child is sixteen years old (some 12 years after starting education)  and although an Adult learner could justifiably gain a GCSE in two year at night school, no infant school would award a GCSE in that time scale. The students mental and physical abilities just do not compare. 

 It seems clear to me that there is a perfectly good reason for having Infant schools, Junior schools, Senior schools and then Colleges and Universities. The experts in teaching understand how the learning requirements, the content and the teaching styles, differ for each age group.  No child enters infant school and is presented with the GCSE syllabus.... why do we do it in Martial Arts?

So its the structure, the syllabus and the teaching knowledge that is missing. Its not good enough to just teach what you were taught, as Martial Artists, Instructors, so called Masters of our art, we have to do better than that.

10 Year Old Black Belt...........a hard working, dedicated, successful child, with a misguided sense of their ability to defend themselves in the real world and an instructor who needs to think more about how they teach, what they teach and when they teach it.

mike@teamblackbelt.com